Review

Smart ForTwo cabriolet

Price  £11,075 - £16,875

Smart ForTwo cabriolet

reviewed by Carbuyer

Pros
  • Unique design
  • Great in town
  • Very cheap to run
Cons
  • Clunky gearbox
  • Lack of storage
  • Only two seats

At a glance

"The highly recognisable Smart ForTwo cabriolet is the smallest convertible car you can buy, and it's ideal for use in built-up areas,  where space is at a premium"

The Smart ForTwo cabriolet convertible is an attractive, head-turning car that is also the smallest convertible you can buy in the UK. It has a clever folding-roof design, while its unique city car proposition – low running costs combined with fun in the sun – does making it tempting to buyers who want more than rivals such as the Toyota iQ offer. The current model is slightly larger than the original Smart car but still only measures 2.69 metres in length, so you can still park it at right angles to the kerb – the smart's unique selling point. The new 1.0-litre petrol petrol engines are reasonably smooth and very frugal, producing very low emissions. The latest 71bhp micro hybrid drive model is also fitted with a stop-start system that helps it to return 67.3mpg. The Smart ForTwo cabriolet comes in three main specifications – entry-level pulse, mid-spec passion and top-of-the-range BRABUS Xclusive.

MPG, running costs & CO2

3.8 / 5

The ForTwo hybrid model is capable of 65mpg

Like the standard model, the ForTwo convertible is capable of returning 65.7mpg in fuel economy from the 71bhp pulse micro hybrid drive model, fitted with stop-start. The hybrid's CO2 emissions also fall below the magic 100g/km mark to qualify for free road tax. In an increasingly common trend, however, the CDI diesel is actually more efficient than the hybrid, returning 85.6mpg and emitting only 87g/km of CO2. If you can afford the Electric Drive model then that model will save you the most money, incurring only a minimal increase to your household electricity costs. All models also fall below insurance group seven.

Interior & comfort

1.2 / 5

Jerky gearbox spoils ForTwo's comfort

As soon as you leave the ForTwo's natural urban-streets habitat, the small, rear-mounted engines across the whole range start to struggle. Once on the motorway or when driving up hills, the engine noise is very loud and tiresome, with only selective acceleration going some way to reducing the din. Also, it's hard to feel relaxed on the motorway with almost every other vehicle seeming to tower over you, and crosswinds are genuinely unsettling. The seats have been re-designed to be much more comfortable than in the past, though. 

Practicality & boot space

2.1 / 5

The Cabriolet has the same 220 litres of boot space as the hardtop

Let's not beat around the bush – the ForTwo cabriolet won’t win any prizes for being practical. While the 220-litre boot is an improvement over the older model, you still can’t load any larger bulky items or suitcases. Plus, it is strictly a two-seater car, but you do get a reasonably sized glove compartment and door bins that can hold mid-sized items such as handbags, bottles and phones. A nice touch is that the removable roof rails slot cleverly into a hidden area behind the boot lid at the back. The main practical plus point for any smart is still its tiny size – if you need to squeeze into tighter-than-tight parking spaces, or just feel like parking sideways on for a quick getaway, there is no better car on the market, so while its general practicality is limited, it is immensely useful for one specific function.

Reliability & safety

2.8 / 5

Poor survey results for Smart

No Smart cars rank in the 2013 Auto Express Driver Power customer satisfaction survey's top 150 cars at all, which is quite telling. Also, Smart itself placed at the very bottom of the manufacturers list in the poll, dropping a further three spots from its 2012 position. This means it's only avoiding dropping off the list entirely because the survey added two extra places in 2013. However, smart is owned by Mercedes, and the ForTwo uses parts from the rest of the company's tried-and-tested line-up. The three-cylinder engines should be reliable, but servicing costs are expensive because they come from Mercedes and Smarts are still relatively rare. Plus, the electrical problems that plagued the original Smart cars have been ironed out, so that is a big improvement over the previous model. Basically, you know a Smart isn’t going to be massively safe – most city cars are limited in this regard – and aren’t going to prove as robust as bigger, more durable cars. This is reflected by the ForTwo only getting four stars in the Euro NCAP crash safety tests, which is a bit disappointing when most cars nowadays sail through with the maximum five stars, but it is worth remembering just how small and light the car is. You do get driver and passenger airbags, plus electronic stability control fitted as standard, but side airbags are available as an optional extra only. You actually only have to look at a Smart ForTwo to gauge how reliable it's going to be – it will serve you well, but anything this small has its limits on the road. 

Engines, drive & performance

1.5 / 5

On inner-city roads the 70bhp model is ideal

The convertible ForTwo cabriolet comes with a choice of three 1.0-litre petrol engines - 71bhp, 84bhp or 102bhp. The entry-level model is actually all city drivers will need to get the best out of the nippy runabout, but anyone who intends to regularly drive their Smart on the open road should look higher in the range. There's generally good visibility, and a very tight turning circle further increases its agility through city traffic. However, twisty roads and roundabouts still highlight the nervous handling that was common in the first-generation models. The jerky semi-automatic gearbox exaggerates this, as it's clunky even when you switch it to manual mode. This is where the Electric Drive model comes up trumps, ditching the gearbox altogether and becoming immediately more enjoyable to drive as a result. Plus, its instant acceleration makes it even better pulling out of junctions.

Price, value for money & options

3.0 / 5

Cheap to buy, but options are limited

The ForTwo cabriolet's value is pretty much in line with the standard model. Entry-level pulse models are therefore cheap to buy, but don’t come with very much equipment. You do get air-conditioning, alloy wheels, Bluetooth and electric windows, while Passion models add swankier extras like sat-nav and a panoramic glass roof.  The sportier BRABUS comes equipped with heated leather seats and a chunkier body kit. If you use Smart's Tailor Made service, BRABUS buyers can personalise their car's colour and interior finish with thousands of combinations – but, naturally, it comes at a price.

What the others say

2.8 / 5
based on 3 reviews
  • 3.5 / 5

    This is the convertible version of the car that most people know simply as the Smart car - although it looks very similar the normal coupe. The model's picked up a cult following since being launched in right-hand drive form in 2001 and is now an everyday sight in towns and cities up and down the country

  • 2.0 / 5

    The ride is overly firm, it's noisy and poor to drive, and the price hike over the coupé is huge.

  • 12.0 / 20

    Turns out their first idea was their best – a city car so abbreviated it made everything else look clinically obese. And it's still the only true radical out there.

Last updated 
2 Sep 2013

Disqus - noscript

Well after reading this review I had to check if it was written about the same car we have just done 42000 miles in over the last 3 1/2 years.

It's difficult to know where to start as I disagree with most major points raised.The first point is the ride in the Pulse is quite firm, reminded me of a soft XR3i.

Don't buy a strictly 2 seater car if you want to try carry more passengers or your little ones around. This is strictly a two seater. I fail to see why most reviews put this as a negative point. If you need a large car that floats along and carries lots of people and luggage don't look at a Smart !

Speed bumps and potholes are best avoided and or driven over slowly, but I do that in other cars as well as a matter of course.
Luggage space is quite adequate IMHO. Four full bags of shopping fit across the rear luggage area and there is always the passenger floor space and seat for three or four more if you are shopping alone. If you want more do it on the internet and get a man to deliver it !

I did manage to fit in a suitcase but only one. The back roof lifts up to give large access to the luggage space as long as roof isn't all the way down ie just top open to what we called position one. In this mode we found it more draughty than with the roof all the way down btw.
The seats are firm but adequate. My only criticism is they don't recline back far enough.Everyone who has been a passenger is surprised how big it is inside. It's just when you look in the mirror at first and wonder why following cars are so close, this can be a little unnerving until you realise they just seem to be close because you are half size really, one gets used to it.

Visibility is excellent except for a small blind spot, an over your shoulder lifesaver check saves any embarrassment when changing lanes or overtaking.
Yes you can overtake, It's quite nippy really.
The air conditioning hardly got used. If it wasn't raining the roof was down even in winter.......Don't knock it till you've tried it, with heater on feet even in winter it's great !

Gearbox is different to many cars, and imho takes a little time to master, and drive smoothly. It can be done but requires anticipation sometimes, especially on hills when setting of at a roundabout etc. I feel it's a quirky gearbox really if that's the right word. 3 gearbox modes in one really. I must say the paddle shift is a gimmick but sometimes fun if you are in that sort of a mood.
I am an auto box chap round town, just let it do the work, and it handles most situations well without you having to intervene,
Almost the final point, and quite important really, build quality is excellent. Far better than other small car models we looked at.

When I look back having owning the Smart Fortwo Pulse Cabriolet it has been a really great fun little car to own.
We enjoyed it so much we are buying another one, same model but different colour. Oh and have ordered an optional sound system upgrade. IMHO with the roof down the standard sound system sounds a bit thin !
In a nutshell, a really fun well built reliable little car but strictly FORTWO :-) 9/10

Sponsored Links

Own this car? Leave your review.