Review

BMW 5 Series saloon

Price  £30,865 - £57,915

BMW 5 Series saloon

reviewed by Carbuyer

Pros
  • Fun to drive
  • Spacious inside
  • Very efficient engines
Cons
  • Somewhat bland styling
  • GT version looks awkward
  • Long and expensive options list

At a glance

The greenest
520d SE 4dr £32,365
The cheapest
518d SE 4dr £30,865
The fastest
550i M Sport Auto 4dr £57,915
Top of the range
550i M Sport Auto 4dr £57,915

"The BMW 5 Series has led the way in the executive class for years and this latest model is no different, offering sporty driving, superb long-distance comfort and an engine to suit everyone."

The BMW 5 Series is the executive car everyone wants to beat. It's been around for over 40 years and seen off all comers, especially the Audi A6, Mercedes E-Class and Jaguar XF. Its secret has always been a mix of great qualities: sporty handling, supple suspension, powerful yet efficient engines, a roomy cabin, excellent build quality and an aspirational image.

It was once quite poorly equipped as standard, but these days even the basic SE model comes loaded with kit. Of course, all of this comes at a price and the 5 Series is not a cheap car. However, that won’t worry most customers, who tend to be business users with a keen eye on their annual tax bill.

The star of the engine line-up is the 520d diesel, which can go from 0-62mph in 7.9 seconds but now returns 65.7mpg and costs just £30 a year to tax. The less powerful 518d takes 9.5 seconds to do 0-62mph, but returns the same fuel economy and CO2 emissions figures. For these reasons, and because it's only around £1,500 cheaper than the 520d, the 518d doesn’t seem worth bothering with.

For comparison's sake, the 520i petrol (which surprisingly, costs more than the 520d) manages just 44.1mpg economy and will set you back £145 a year in road tax. All that and it's still only as fast from 0-62mph as the diesel.

Lovers of BMW's smooth and refined six-cylinder engines are still well served higher up the engine range by the 530d diesel and 535i petrol. Higher still sits the V8-engined 550i and above that, the supercar-baiting M5.

Fortunately, these models don’t have a monopoly on driving pleasure. All versions of the 5 Series are great to drive, with direct steering that's full of feel, a sporty rear-wheel-drive chassis, powerful brakes and excellent high-speed handling. They’ll also transport you along the motorway all day long in total comfort.

BMW recently tweaked the 5 Series trim levels so there are now just three versions: SE, Luxury and M Sport. SE is so well equipped that it's hard to make a case for the others. Its highlights include sat nav, leather trim and DAB digital radio. Luxury trim adds larger wheels and smarter detailing, while M Sport goes all-out with sporty add-ons and firmer suspension (fortunately you can choose softer SE springs as a no-cost option).

The 5 Series was awarded the maximum five-star Euro NCAP safety rating, but if you have any lingering doubts, you can take comfort from the fact that it also has a suite of advanced braking, traction and cornering systems and hill-start assistance, as well as front and rear parking sensors.

MPG, running costs & CO2

3.9 / 5

Efficient diesel engines make the BMW 5 Series surprisingly cheap for company-car users – but private buyers shouldn’t discount petrols

Engines, drive & performance

5 / 5

Even entry-level BMW 5 Series models are rewarding to drive – it's easily the best handling car in this class

Interior & comfort

4.2 / 5

The BMW 5 Series has an impressive high-quality, stylish cabin. Most are comfortable, but those with sports suspension can be harsh

Practicality & boot space

4 / 5

Interior and boot are both very spacious, making the BMW 5 Series an excellent long-distance cruiser or family car

Reliability & safety

4.1 / 5

No big concerns in either area – the BMW 5 Series is a class leader here, too

What the others say

4.5 / 5
based on 4 reviews
5 / 5
"Elegant, grown up and supremely efficient, the 5-series is a major stepping stone in man's climb from primeval soup to intelligent master race."
5 / 5
"While BMWs have always been renowed for handling they have often been criticised for having an uncomfortable ride. But this 5 Series has no such issues."
4 / 5
"BMW's most profitable model is now also its most well rounded. The firm has addressed key criticisms without ruining the strengths of the old car, and wrapped it up in a successful new body with subtle detailing that grows on you."
4 / 5
“The BMW 5 Series is still at the head of the executive-car class, thanks to superb build quality, classy looks and a driving experience its rivals can't match.”
What owners say 
4.2970108695652
4.3 /5 based on 368 reviews
68%
 of people would recommend this car to a friend
Last updated 
28 May 2015
Own this car? Leave your review.