Watchdog: Owner takes issue with dealer’s clutch advice

Repair recommendation given during recall work but RAV4 had recently been fixed

Taking your car into a garage for one thing and then being asked to pay for more work that’s been uncovered is not uncommon, and the unexpected expense can be a frustration to motorists.

The question is, though, how can you be sure the diagnosis can be trusted? Is the dealer just being overly cautious, or trying to make a quick buck out of customers?

Tim Curtis of Goodmanham, in the East Riding of Yorkshire, was left asking exactly this after his Toyota RAV4 was called into his local dealer, Hull John Roe, to have airbag recall work carried out.

The off-roader was booked in for February but on collection, Tim was presented with a visual safety report advising that his clutch needed immediate attention. However, Tim was far from convinced, as – unknown to the Toyota main dealer – just a week prior to his car being recalled, it had broken down and his local mechanic at Beadle Motors had fitted a new clutch and bearing.

Tim said: “I didn’t ask for the visual health check to be carried out. My car is fully serviced every year, so there would have been no need for such an inspection.”

Even so, Tim took his RAV4 back to Beadle Motors, which took the car on a test drive and said there was nothing wrong. With the two garages disagreeing, Tim contacted us and we advised to have an independent inspection carried out.

Tim paid for this and the report found that Beadle Motors had carried out an “acceptable repair”, and failed to agree with the original Hull John Roe diagnosis. We contacted Toyota to find out more about Tim’s case with Hull John Roe.

A Toyota spokesperson told us its dealer was standing by its findings “regardless of the fact that the clutch was recently replaced by a non-Toyota workshop”. He added: “The dealer has offered Mr Curtis a second opinion in their workshop, given him independent advice and also fuel, all free of charge, but unfortunately Mr Curtis has lost faith with Hull John Roe.”

Tim concluded: “It angers me to think that customers could be passing over money for work that did not even need to be undertaken in the first place.”

Most Popular

New 2022 Toyota RAV4 Adventure revealed
Toyota RAV4 Adventure
Toyota RAV4
14 Sep 2021

New 2022 Toyota RAV4 Adventure revealed

New Volkswagen Passat set to launch in 2023
2023 Volkswagen Passat
Volkswagen Passat
9 Sep 2021

New Volkswagen Passat set to launch in 2023

Top 10 best small estates 2021
Skoda Octavia Estate
Skoda Octavia Estate
22 Sep 2021

Top 10 best small estates 2021

Tips & advice

View All
Car dashboard warning lights: the complete guide
Car dashboard symbols and meanings
Tips and advice
10 Aug 2021

Car dashboard warning lights: the complete guide

Electric car charging stations: a complete guide
Electric car charging station
Tips and advice
3 Jun 2021

Electric car charging stations: a complete guide

PCP vs HP – which type of car finance is right for you?
PCP vs HP
Tips and advice
15 Jun 2021

PCP vs HP – which type of car finance is right for you?

Average speed cameras: how do they work?
Average speed cameras: how do they work?
Tips and advice
23 Jul 2021

Average speed cameras: how do they work?

Best cars

View All
Top 10 best car interiors 2021
Peugeot 208 hatchback
Best cars
25 Jun 2021

Top 10 best car interiors 2021

Top 10 best electric cars 2021
Volkswagen ID.3
Best cars
12 Aug 2021

Top 10 best electric cars 2021

Top 10 best cheap-to-run cars 2021
Toyota Prius front 3/4 cornering
Best cars
10 Jun 2021

Top 10 best cheap-to-run cars 2021

The UK's top 10 fastest hot hatchbacks
Mercedes AMG A45 - rear
Hot hatches
25 Jun 2021

The UK's top 10 fastest hot hatchbacks