Watchdog: Driver baffled by intermittent stop/start

Mazda owner believes system is faulty but dealer and manufacturer don't agree

Stop/start is a piece of emissions-busting tech designed to kick in only when it’s beneficial. As you pull up to a set of lights, for example, the system makes a split-second decision about whether switching off the engine – then on again as the lights change – will use more energy than just leaving it running.

So how can you tell if the setup’s working properly? That’s the question frustrating Les Stone, of Salford, Gtr Manchester, who argues the i-stop system in his 62-reg Mazda CX-5 is suspiciously intermittent. Yet after repeated trips to RRG Mazda in Manchester, the dealer concluded there was no fault with the SUV’s stop/start.

Les told Carbuyer's sister site, Auto Express: “My dealer explained that anything which drained the battery, like the heated rear screen or the air-con, would affect whether it worked. Yet I noticed it would work first thing in the morning from cold, with everything switched on, but then not after a drive on the motorway. It didn’t make sense.”

We called Mazda for help, but it also argued Les’s i-stop wasn’t necessarily faulty. A spokesman said: “Myriad factors based on electrical loadings influence whether the i-stop works. It’s incredibly complicated. Ambient temperature will have an impact, for example, or even switching the cabin air flow from the windscreen to your face.”

The same journey, made on two different days, might therefore result in entirely different pattens of stop/start operation, the spokesman argued, adding: “If it hasn’t kicked in, it’s for a good reason. If it was faulty, there would have been a warning light and it would have been picked up by the dealer during diagnostic tests.”

If Les is still unconvinced, the consumer desk at Auto Express suggested he asks his dealer to make another CX-5 available for an extended test drive. He can then at least establish if the same intermittent pattern applies.

What should you do if it happens to you?

Comparing your car to an identical new model is a great way to test dealer claims there’s nothing wrong with yours. If you find it performs the same, you can assume it is a ‘characteristic’. If your garage refuses to offer a comparison test, however, we’d advise escalating the complaint to the manufacturer.

Recommended

Top 3 used medium-size SUVs for £25,000
Carbuyer - Top 3 used medium-size SUVs for £25,000
Land Rover Discovery Sport SUV
6 Mar 2020

Top 3 used medium-size SUVs for £25,000

Cheap fun cars: our picks from £1,000 to £10,000
Honda Civic Type R front
Toyota
5 Jan 2021

Cheap fun cars: our picks from £1,000 to £10,000

New Mazda MX-30 electric SUV: full prices and specs released
Mazda MX-30
Mazda
28 Sep 2020

New Mazda MX-30 electric SUV: full prices and specs released

100th Anniversary editions of Mazda MX-5, CX-30 and Mazda3
Mazda MX-5 100th Anniversary and Mazda R360
Mazda
3 Aug 2020

100th Anniversary editions of Mazda MX-5, CX-30 and Mazda3

Most Popular

Best new car deals 2021
i3deals
Deals
15 Jan 2021

Best new car deals 2021

Best 4x4s and SUVs
Peugeot 3008 SUV rear 3/4 tracking
Family SUVs
14 Jan 2021

Best 4x4s and SUVs

2021 scrappage schemes: the complete guide
Tips and advice
7 Jan 2021

2021 scrappage schemes: the complete guide