Watchdog: Insurer and BMW go head-to-head over fault

Owner left in limbo as cover provider and manufacturer disagree over leaky air vent

It’s not often Auto Express hears from a motorist who’s been left without a car as their dealer and insurer can’t agree over who’s to blame for a fault. But that’s the unhelpful situation faced by reader Stephen Ripley of Dunfermline, Fife, who was left in a courtesy car for weeks.

He told us heavy rain had flooded the boot of his year-old BMW M135i last October, so he took it to dealer Eastern BMW in Newbridge, Edinburgh, expecting a free fix. But the warranty claim was rejected, as BMW argued the leaky air vent was down to accident damage, which had caused the seal to fail and the car to leak. It recommended he call his insurer instead.

Stephen did just that, but after inspecting the vehicle, cover provider Tesco concluded there was no visible accident damage to corroborate BMW’s claims, even beneath the bumper, which it removed during one of its two inspections. Tesco argued the part must be faulty, or it was damaged during factory fitting, and refused to pay out, too.

In the meantime, Stephen searched BMW owner forums online and found other motorists complaining about a leaky vent in the boot of their cars. Auto Express also called a number of BMW dealers, and was told there’d been a history of leaks with this part. However, after weeks of wrangling, it was Stephen’s insurer that finally agreed to submit a no-fault claim, and gave him a courtesy car while his was being fixed.

Stephen said: “That still means losing my no-claims bonus and paying an excess, which seems totally unreasonable in the circumstances.” Auto Express called BMW but it refused to comment.

Instead, its spokesman explained BMW had carried out four separate inspections – once by a regional master technician – and added: “All of these experts arrived at the same conclusion. Evidence supports that the leak has occurred due to an impact on the vehicle and thus is not a manufacturing defect and does not qualify for a warranty claim.”

Stephen told Auto Express he was “really disappointed” with the response, adding: “I’m going to have to pursue this further, as I feel I’ve been bullied and misled by BMW, and I’m now massively out of pocket.”

Recommended

BMW 1 Series hatchback review
BMW 1 Series M Sport
BMW 1 Series
8 Mar 2021

BMW 1 Series hatchback review

BMW 1 Series owner reviews
BMW 1 Series M Sport
BMW 1 Series
8 Mar 2021

BMW 1 Series owner reviews

Best luxury small cars
Best cars
7 Sep 2020

Best luxury small cars

BMW iDrive explained: what is it and how does it work?
The iDrive infotainment system is controlled via this rotary dial on the centre console
BMW
8 Apr 2021

BMW iDrive explained: what is it and how does it work?

Most Popular

New Toyota GR86 unveiled
2021 Toyota GR86 - front 3/4 view
Toyota
6 Apr 2021

New Toyota GR86 unveiled

Best new car deals 2021
i20
Deals
9 Apr 2021

Best new car deals 2021

UK road tax rules for 2021 explained
2021 Road Tax explained
Tips and advice
8 Apr 2021

UK road tax rules for 2021 explained

Tips & advice

View All
Car dashboard warning lights: the complete guide
Tips and advice
28 Dec 2020

Car dashboard warning lights: the complete guide

Electric car charging stations: a complete guide
Tips and advice
10 Nov 2020

Electric car charging stations: a complete guide

PCP vs HP – what's the difference?
Tips and Advice
23 Mar 2020

PCP vs HP – what's the difference?

Average speed cameras: how do they work?
Average speed cameras: how do they work?
Tips and advice
24 Feb 2021

Average speed cameras: how do they work?

Best cars

View All
Best car interiors
Best cars
10 Mar 2020

Best car interiors

Best electric cars
Best cars
24 Dec 2020

Best electric cars

Best cheap-to-run cars
Toyota Prius front 3/4 cornering
Best cars
1 Feb 2021

Best cheap-to-run cars

The UK's top 10 fastest hot hatchbacks
Hot hatches
9 Apr 2020

The UK's top 10 fastest hot hatchbacks