Euro NCAP: how safe is my car?
Car safety is rapidly evolving, but what is a Euro NCAP score?
Safety is one of the most important factors for many of us when shopping for a new car. Despite this, potential buyers once had little more to go on than a carmaker's reputation and the list of safety equipment fitted to its cars. Fortunately, the foundation of Euro NCAP put an end to this, introducing standardised tests to put cars through their crash-safety paces.
Established in 1997, Euro NCAP is an independent organisation that buys cars anonymously before subjecting them to stringent crash tests and rating their performance. You may have seen or heard the phrase "five-star Euro NCAP crash safety rating" in TV and magazine adverts – and such a rating has become the norm for today's latest cars. This is a testament to safety technology having progressed a long way in recent years.
But how does Euro NCAP work out its ratings and what do they mean for you?
What is Euro NCAP?
Euro NCAP ('New Car Assessment Programme') is the organisation that tests the safety of cars you can buy in Europe. It's not interested in other factors, such as fuel-efficiency or top speed – its only concern is how safe a car is if it's involved in a collision.
Many car manufacturers had established a reputation for safety long before Euro NCAP came into being and for many the word of a car's maker was sufficient promise of its safety. Such marketing wasn't always based on facts, though, and it was near-impossible to know how one car compared to another when it came to crash safety.
Euro NCAP's solution to this was to buy cars anonymously and independently crash-test them, using the same rigorous procedure for every car and awarding each one a rating out of five stars.
Two decades since the first Euro NCAP crash tests took place, a five-star result – awarded to only the very safest cars – has become almost mandatory when a new car is launched in Europe.
Not every single car can be tested, though. Euro NCAP members (a selection of government departments and independent organizations from across Europe) can 'sponsor' the test of a vehicle they think deserves some scrutiny, and the cars tested tend to be the biggest-selling models. Vehicles for testing are purchased anonymously from normal car dealers before being prepared for the tests.
Euro NCAP retesting
It's important to remember that a Euro NCAP star rating only serves as a snapshot in time. Although a new car might excel in the most stringent of crash tests available when it's launched, you can bet that the car which replaces it in the showroom several years later will be even safer.
Euro NCAP star ratings are awarded with the understanding that they expire after six years, although a car can be retested at any time, and the organization now performs reviews every 12 months, checking that safety equipment fitted to the test car is still provided, so the car is still representative of current production. If a car is facelifted or updated, Euro NCAP will work with the manufacturer to check that its original test findings are still valid.
The importance of regular testing was brought into sharp focus when the Fiat Punto recieved the organisation's first ever zero-star rating. This shocked many, because it originally received the full five-star rating. However, this previous rating was issued in 2005, when today's Punto was launched under its original Grande Punto name.
In the 12 years between the tests, rival superminis such as the Ford Fiesta have gone through several development generations, with safety a big focus for each new version launched. Crash-prevention and driver assistance technology has become far more sophisticated, too – features such as autonomous emergency braking simply weren't available when the Fiat Punto was launched.
It's hardly surprising, then, that the five-star-rated 2017 Ford Fiesta is a far safer car than the 2005 Fiat Punto, despite them receiving the same rating when new. An awful lot of progress has been made between the launch of the two cars.
How are cars tested?
There are several tests, each designed to reflect real-world accidents as much as possible. The range of tests has recently been expanded to accommodate some of the more sophisticated safety technology now being offered on cars, such as automatic braking and speed assistance.
One of the ways that Euro NCAP measures the safety of cars is with crash-test dummies. These highly advanced human-sized dummies are full of sensors that record what might happen to a real person if they experienced the same impact. The tests look at adult and child occupants separately, with smaller crash test dummies used to simulate infants in child seats.
This is a test of a car's safety performance in a front impact with another vehicle. Before 2020, this involved the test vehicle crashing into a barrier at 40mph and Euro NCAP measuring how well its occupants were protected. However, from 2020 onwards the test has changed so that the car travelling at 31mph (50km/h) collides with a moving barrier travelling at the same speed, better representing a collision between two vehicles. This tests airbags, seatbelts and the general structural strength of the car. From 2020, Euro NCAP also assesses the damage the test car causes to the car it collides with. This move should help indicate the potential of larger vehicles to cause unacceptable damage to smaller cars in accidents.
This tests how a car would protect its occupants if struck by another vehicle from the side. A large, heavy robot crashes into the side of the car (roughly where the doors are) and any 'injuries' to the dummies are recorded. For 2020, this test was made more stringent, with the far-side crash-test dummy now also evaluated, along with any injuries caused by occupants colliding with each other in a side impact. This will help assess the latest generation of central airbags that are designed to prevent these injuries.
Pole side impact
This is roughly what happens if you lose control of your car and it skids sideways into a tree or lamp-post. It's similar to the car-to-car-side test, but with the car moving rather than the object. The pole comes into contact with the car roughly in line with the doors.
It isn't just cars' occupants that Euro NCAP cares about. Pedestrians can be protected with good car design, too. This test simulates collisions with adult and child pedestrians and assesses how well the vehicle's design protects them.
Child protection systems
Euro NCAP assesses how well a car can accommodate proper child safety seats in the safest configuration. The dummies used in the crash tests roughly correspond with a 18-month-old and a three-year-old – these sit in child restraints on the back seat.
Neck injury caused by sudden crashes can be devastating, but can be somewhat alleviated with good car design. Interior features like head restraints can mitigate the risk of whiplash injury.
Speed assistance systems and seatbelt reminders
Features such as speed assistance (which remind you what the speed limit is on a particular stretch of road) and seatbelt reminders (which beep until you put your seatbelt on) are considered important by Euro NCAP.
Autonomous emergency braking (AEB)
This relatively new technology enables the car to slow itself down if it detects a collision is imminent. Tested on three types of road (roughly equating to urban roads, rural roads and motorways), these systems can prevent some serious crashes. Euro NCAP examines how well they work.
AEB Vulnerable Road Users
Introduced in 2018, AEB Vulnerable Road Users (AEB VRU) is the newest Euro NCAP area. It includes tests that determine how well a vehicle can detect cyclists and avoid collisions with them, potentially saving lives. This "presents new challenges to car manufacturers" according to Euro NCAP, because wide-angle sensors and complex software algorithms are needed to detect fast-moving cyclists in good time and correctly identify potential collisions, without false activations.
Electronic Stability Control
Modern cars include complex technology that helps prevent skidding. This is one of the most important developments in car safety, as it means that a slight loss of control or grip (particularly in wet or slippery conditions) can be managed by the car rather than escalating into a potentially lethal skid.
What do Euro NCAP results mean?
On the Euro NCAP website, the results of each of these tests are published in extreme detail. You can use the site to search for every measured part of the test, from whether the autonomous emergency braking works to the danger to individual body parts for infant occupants.
But this approach is generally too complicated for most uses. In order to simplify things, Euro NCAP gives each car an overall star rating out of five. For example, the Hyundai i10 scores four out of five, the Dacia Logan scores three out of five and the VW Passat scores five out of five.
So if a five-star car crashes into a three-star car, the five-star car will fare better?
Euro NCAP assessments are carried out with a car's class in mind. That means huge 4x4s aren’t compared directly to tiny city cars. As such, Euro NCAP results aren't always comparable.
Generally speaking, the taller a car is, the better it will fare in an accident. This is because a taller car will more heavily damage a lower car if they collide. As such, a three-star 4x4 might still come off better than a five-star city car if they crash into each other.
To help understand how Euro NCAP rates cars, there's a quick guide to star ratings below:
5 stars - Overall good performance in crash protection. Well equipped with robust crash protection.4 stars - Overall good performance in crash protection. Additional crash avoidance technology may be present.3 stars - Average to good occupant protection. Lacking crash avoidance technology.2 stars - Nominal crash protection, but lacking crash avoidance technology.1 star - Marginal crash protection.
Euro NCAP categories explained
In the time since Euro NCAP ratings were first introduced in 2009, they have evolved to include four important areas. Vulnerable Road Users was introduced in 2018 to tell owners how adept a car is at avoiding accidents with pedestrians and cyclists – a rapidly evolving area of safety technology.
Adult occupant protection
A series of crash tests determines how safe the interior of the car is for adults, generating an overall score out of 100%. The subject vehicle is crashed into rigid and deformable barriers at set speeds, experiences a side impact with a pole and a mobile barrier representing another vehicle. Crash-test dummies loaded with precise sensors record the impact an occupant would experience, while high-speed video records exactly how the car deforms and safety features like airbags function.
Child occupant protection
Euro NCAP also scores the protection a car offers child occupants out of 100%. This aspect of the test was introduced in 2013 and added to in 2016. It assesses the protection provided by the vehicle's child-restraint systems in a crash and its ability to accommodate child seats and restraints of different designs and sizes, measuring the location of belt buckles, ISOFIX anchorage points, along with the ease of installation of a range of child seats.
Vulnerable Road Users
This section of the test was named Vulnerable Road Users (VRU) in 2018. While the first two sections above measure safety for the driver and passengers in a crash, this category shifts the focus to how well a vehicle protects pedestrians and cyclists from harm. In a frontal collision with a crash-test dummy, head, upper leg and lower leg impacts are measured and scored.
Autonomous Emergency Braking (AEB) technology that scans the road ahead for pedestrians and cyclists is also tested. Designed to automatically identify potential hazards and warn the driver, these systems can automatically apply the brakes to help mitigate or avoid a collision. In 2018 a new AEB Cyclist test was added, assessing the ability of new models to detect and react to crossing cyclists and cyclists heading in the same direction as the car.
The Safety Assist category judges the inclusion and performance of driver assistance technologies that "support safe driving to avoid accidents and mitigate injuries". This includes everything from seatbelt reminders and fatigue warnings that prompt you to pull over and take a break, to speed limiters, lane-departure warning systems, electronic stability control and autonomous emergency braking.
Eek – my car only scored three out of five!
There's no need to panic. Modern cars are generally very safe, and a three-star car built in the past few years could be much better at protecting its occupants than a five-star car from the nineties.
In addition, a car can be marked down for design aspects other than simple crash protection and body strength. For example, a new model might lose points if it lacks a seatbelt warning alarm.
And as manufacturers build safer and safer cars, Euro NCAP devises tougher and tougher tests. The tests undergone by cars this year will be more thorough and more demanding than those in 2012 or 2008. And cars are re-tested and re-evaluated all the time, ensuring that a model's Euro NCAP safety rating remains current throughout its time on sale.
Realistically, the difference between a three-star and a five-star car won't necessarily protect you in an accident. Safe driving and correct use of the fitted safety features is as important in a Volvo V40 as it is in any other car.
What about the new dual rating system?
Euro NCAP introduced a dual rating system in 2016, although not all cars will be awarded two different sets of stars. If you see a car with two different star ratings, one refers to the car’s score in its most basic specification, while the other shows how the car fared when fitted with an optional safety pack. These packs tend to include advanced safety technology like autonomous emergency braking and a lane-departure warning system.