Best medium size and family SUVs
The mid-sized SUV market is one of the UK's fastest-growing, with buyers flocking to benefit from handsome styling and family-friendly practicality. But which is best?
The mid-size SUV is responsible for changing the motoring landscape more than any other type of car in recent years, such has its popularity increased. The wave of SUV-inspired crossover vehicles that accounts for so many new-car sales today was spearheaded by the Nissan Qashqai, which proved that a sturdy and practical yet compact vehicle was just what families were looking for.
Although there were medium-sized SUVs before the Qashqai, very few of them were as versatile and easy to live with. Many were merely shrunken versions of larger off-roaders and somewhat over-engineered for family life, while others were simply too agricultural to be truly enjoyable. The first Qashqai was a model with all the everyday versatility of an SUV, but the running costs and road manners of a small hatchback.
The Qashqai and its rivals have become a force to be reckoned with; many people now choose this kind of car instead of a conventional hatchback or estate, which don’t offer the raised driving position, extensive luggage compartment and adventurous looks of a medium SUV. It seems that every month another maker carmaker gets in on the act with an offering of its own, so this class has never been so competitive.
If you’d rather have something not quite as big there are plenty of smaller models to choose from, and we’ve looked at every single SUV on the market, whatever its size, to figure out which are the best you can buy, so there really is an SUV or crossover for everybody.
Meanwhile, here’s our shortlist of the 10 best medium SUVs you can buy today.
The Peugeot 3008 is an incredibly capable all-rounder. It's been given a very mature, sophisticated look on the outside, but it's the interior that really impresses with its sleek, space-age dashboard. Peugeot's clever i-Cockpit instrument cluster replaces traditional dials with a hi-res screen you can customise like Audi's Virtual Cockpit, and its other displays and buttons exude concept-car cool. Elsewhere, high-quality fabrics have been used throughout to upmarket and elegant effect and there’s plenty of space for five and their luggage. Couple that with a range of superb engines, including a 1.6-litre diesel that can achieve 69mpg, a comfortable ride and plenty of equipment, and you have one of our favourite mid-sized SUVs.
The Skoda Karoq shares its underpinnings with the SEAT Ateca and has many of the same great qualities as a result. The Karoq trumps the Ateca in some respects too, thanks to elements such as its VarioFlex rear seats that slide independent of each other, making the car more versatile inside. The Karoq has a slightly softer suspension setup than the Ateca, which results in excellent ride quality – something that may be of more importance to buyers, particularly those with families, than handling. The Karoq has one of the biggest boots in the class, beating those in the Volkswagen Tiguan and Peugeot 3008, and you’re very likely to find an engine suited to how you’ll use the car because of the large and impressive selection of VW group engines offered.
You could be forgiven for thinking SEAT has been building SUVs for years, such is the excellence of the Ateca, the Spanish brand’s first foray into this class. With handsome styling, a practical interior and a surprisingly low list price, the Ateca is great value for money. It offers a wide range of engines and the option of four-wheel drive, although choosing that does have a negative impact on boot space. The Ateca is a SEAT, so it ought to be good to drive – and it is! We reckon it offers more driver appeal than the Volkswagen Tiguan, but the ride is firmer than some of the other models on this list. The 1.6-litre diesel engine is the cheapest to run, but still isn’t awfully sluggish, and there are plenty more powerful engine choices, all of which are reasonably economical.
Volkswagen has styled its Tiguan medium-sized SUV in the same sharp, unmistakeable vein as the rest of its range, and there’s no doubting it’s more visually striking than ever before. This helps to increase the car’s appeal – now more relevant than ever as the Tiguan is effectively a more expensive version of the SEAT Ateca that we rate so highly. Like the Ateca, it’s available with a wide range of engines and specification levels, plus you can choose a four-wheel-drive version if you’re looking for extra winter grip. As we’ve come to expect from Volkswagen, the Tiguan has a well-finished interior and is quiet and comfortable on the move. There’s a big boot and plenty of space for passengers, too. But ultimately, apart from a smoother ride, it doesn’t offer much over the cheaper SEAT Ateca, so the Spanish car is our preferred choice.
The Renault Kadjar is a sister car of the crossover that kicked off the craze, the Nissan Qashqai. You can choose from a 1.2-litre petrol engine or economical 1.5 and 1.6-litre diesels, while four-wheel drive is an option. More importantly, the Kadjar is an extremely practical SUV with a huge boot, loads of storage and plenty of space front and back. If you want even more space, the larger Renault Koleos has similar styling to the Kadjar but a bigger interior and more powerful engines. Owners praised the Kadjar’s low running costs in our 2017 Driver Power satisfaction survey. Compared to the Qashqai, the Kadjar has a bigger boot, a longer warranty and a lower price. The other big difference is the styling – while the Qashqai looks rather conservative, the Kadjar has a bold appearance and just a little more personality than the Qashqai.
If you plan on keeping your SUV for a while, the Kia Sportage should appeal thanks to its seven-year warranty – the longest in the industry. Keeping with the sensible reasons, the 1.7-litre diesel is also economical, returning around 61mpg and will appeal to company-car drivers thanks to its low CO2 emissions. The Sportage appeals to the heart, too, with dramatic styling and plenty of room for the family to head off on holiday, with a roof box and bikes attached to the roof rails. Kia’s medium-sized SUV is good to drive, too, with sharp steering and hardly any body lean in corners. In our 2017 Driver Power satisfaction survey, it finished in 12th place out of 75 models, with a five-star Euro NCAP score proving its safety credentials.
The latest Honda CR-V only comes with petrol or hybrid powertrains but both suit the popular SUV nicely. The hybrid uses a 2.0-litre engine and a pair of electric motors, whereas the pure petrol model has a 1.5-litre engine with either 171bhp and a manual gearbox or 190bhp with a CVT automatic. The more powerful version is our favourite and gives the car a top speed of 131mph and a 0-62mph-time of 9.3 seconds. Fuel economy of up to 32.5mpg isn’t amazing, but the less powerful two-wheel drive manual car manages almost 39mpg. Honda has improved the CR-V's steering and made the suspension more compliant, while the interior has an upmarket feel and a decent infotainment system. For the first time, the CR-V is also available with seven seats, although, as with most seven-seat SUVs, the third row is really only comfortable for children.
The Vauxhall Grandland X is one of the more sensible choices in the SUV class but that’s not necessarily a bad thing. The car is comfortable thanks to a soft suspension setup, and very practical thanks to a large boot and five spacious seats. The interior is conservatively styled but logically laid out, and even the entry-level model comes with lots of standard equipment. There’s a choice of a 128bhp 1.2-litre petrol engine or a 118bhp 1.6-litre diesel, with both proving to be flexible and smooth. Our only major complaint about the car is that it looks a little plain next to some of its more stylish rivals.
The Mazda CX-5 has been one of the best SUVs to drive since its launch. Mazda cites its MX-5 sports car as inspiration, and as far-fetched as this sounds, the steering, suspension and gearbox all feel pin-sharp. The most economical engine is a 2.2-litre diesel with front-wheel drive, returning up to 56.5mpg. A subtle facelift has tweaked its appearance to stave off the ageing process and the infotainment system has been updated. As well as being fun for the driver, the CX-5 is practical thanks to its large boot and spacious rear seats. Mazda has a good reputation for reliability, too, so it’s unlikely a CX-5 would cause you any problems in that regard.
The Toyota RAV4 is a hybrid-only SUV that should appeal to company-car drivers and family buyers alike. It can manage up to 50.4mpg with CO2 emissions of 105g/km, impressive figures for an SUV, and its interior is a mix of robust materials and quality finishes that should survive the rigours of family life. The RAV4's 580-litre boot helps make this a very practical car too. The 2.5-litre petrol engine and electric motor combination provides 215bhp in the front-wheel drive version or 219bhp in the four-wheel drive version, making the RAV4 quick for an SUV.